There is no doubt that quality education creates a better society. More importantly, providing education for young minds is what every nation aims at because they are the future. Colleges, institutes, and universities are essential to produce better citizens, and therefore they are a significant aspect of every student’s life.
Autonomous vs Non-Autonomous College
The main difference between Autonomous and Non-Autonomous College is that an Autonomous College isn’t controlled by the government or its agencies. On the other hand, a Non-Autonomous College is directly under the control of the government (or its departments) and works according to the laws and policies created by it.
Autonomous College is not bound to follow the academics and other cultural aspects laid by the government or its subsidiaries. An Autonomous College has total power over its curriculum, finances, staff organization, and daily activities and can work independently without the influence or orders of any other entity or organization.
A Non-Autonomous College doesn’t exercise full control over the college’s academics, curriculum, and culture. Instead, a Non-Autonomous College is controlled by the government, and it decides the rules, regulations, and other important aspects of the college. For example, all the government colleges are Non-Autonomous because they follow the government’s curriculum.
Comparison Table Between Autonomous And Non-Autonomous College
| Parameters of Comparison | Autonomous College | Non-Autonomous College |
| Definition | A college with complete control over its activities and curriculum | A college that the government controls |
| Admission Process | It is easy to get into an Autonomous College because the admission process is decided by the college head. | It is tough to get into Non-Autonomous College because the admission process is merit-based |
| Examination | Exams are easy as compared to Non-Autonomous College | Exams are tough |
| Rules | Rules in an Autonomous College are often hard | Rules are somewhat easy as the government sets them. |
| Curriculum design | The curriculum is designed in a way so that graduates are suitable for industrial needs. | The curriculum is often outdated. |
| Monitoring | No external body monitors the college, and hence rules are sometimes overlooked. | Government bodies monitor these colleges. |
What is Autonomous College?
An Autonomous College, university, or institute is a type of institution that designs and applies its kind of curriculum. In other words, Autonomous Colleges exercise autonomy over their daily practices, and they are not bound to follow the curriculum suggested by the government. However, Autonomous Colleges do follow the necessary rules and regulations like anti-ragging laws laid by the government to ensure the safety and security of the students and staff.
The freedom to choose what is right for the students and the college is one of the advantages of an Autonomous College. While designing their courses, Autonomous Colleges keep in mind the industry’s needs and prepare students for the competitive world. Also, since the college authority makes all the decisions, they are fast and to the benefit of everyone at the college.
Autonomous Colleges sometimes misuse their freedom which hinders the sense of advancement they provide. For example, since the admission process is in the hands of college authorities, they might favor one student over another due to wrong reasons like popularity or money. Also, Autonomous Colleges sometimes charge inaccurate fees, and that is the reason why financially backward students can’t afford an education at Autonomous Colleges and experience discrimination.
What is Non-Autonomous College?
Non-Autonomous Colleges or universities fully adapt the curriculum and regulations set by the government. Non-Autonomous Colleges are completely affiliated with the government and don’t exercise any freedom over the day-to-day activities and academics conducted in the college.
Since the government aims for the good of its citizens, Non-Autonomous Colleges are accessible by anyone irrespective of their financial situation or otherwise. Non-Autonomous Colleges have viable fees, and the admission is based on merit, which means only the deserving students get selected. Moreover, the government rules ensure that every student remains safe from every threat. However, if a student is discriminated against, the authorities take it seriously, conduct suitable actions, and make sure that the college is safe.
Non-Autonomous Colleges are often very slow because an order has to pass through several checks before it is accepted. This process is suitable for cross-checking the policies, but it is also time-consuming, and students can’t afford to be late in this ever-competitive world. This slow working is the reason why Non-Autonomous Colleges run outdated syllabi their students don’t meet the current industrial requirements and remain unemployed. Also, the examination and results in Non-Autonomous Colleges are late and challenging compared to other colleges.
Main Differences Between Autonomous And Non-Autonomous College
- An Autonomous College controls and decides the curriculum, whereas Non-Autonomous Colleges follow the curriculum determined by the government.
- Getting into an Autonomous College is easier because the decision lies in the hands of college authority, whereas getting into a Non-Autonomous College is relatively challenging. After all, admission is based on merits and an entrance exam.
- Internal examinations in an Autonomous College are more manageable than that of a Non-Autonomous College.
- Autonomous Colleges have complex rules and regulations, whereas Non-Autonomous Colleges have flexible and easy management.
- Autonomous Colleges design curriculum according to industry needs, whereas Non-Autonomous Colleges run outdated syllabi.
- Autonomous Colleges are not monitored by an external body, whereas government entities monitor Non-Autonomous Colleges.
Conclusion
Both Autonomous and Non-Autonomous Colleges have their pros and cons, which is why none is better than the other. The decision as to which type of college a student should choose is highly subjective and depends upon the student’s needs.
To summarize, Autonomous Colleges have autonomy over their syllabus and academics and aren’t bound to follow the curriculum made by the government. Autonomous Colleges are great if you are willing to pay more to get a better education. Non-Autonomous Colleges strictly follow the government and its rules and curriculum. Non-Autonomous Colleges charge relatively low fees and try to provide the best level of education to the students.
References
- https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=c8fhDwAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PA131&dq=autonomous+colleges&ots=4DYtXNiCei&sig=HkHMeRFEQfhbnaCfIYXxzR6GpTA
- http://www.niepa.ac.in/download/Publications/JEPA_(15%20years)/JEPA%202019_Vol-33(1-4)/JEPA_Jan_2019_1.pdf#page=19